Goodbye Claude, hello Pi(caleb.software)
805 points by karagenit 3 days ago | 485 comments
tl;dr: A longtime Claude Code user is switching to Pi, citing frustrations like Claude Code's late AGENTS.md support, broken multi-tab IDE integration, buggy VSCode extension, bloated system prompts (the Bash tool alone uses ~3,000 tokens), and 244 releases this year that constantly churn system prompts. The author argues Claude Code lacks product vision, feeling like engineers piling on features without someone empowered to say "no." Pi's stability, minimalism, and extensibility won them over — they built a missing multi-tab feature as an extension in 20 minutes.
HN Discussion:
  • ↑Pi's control and extensibility make it the superior harness for orchestrating agents
  • ↑Daily driving Pi has been great, with custom extensions filling feature gaps
  • ↓Using non-native harnesses with Anthropic models is risky due to ToS, hidden API features, and inferior compaction
  • ↓The article explains why leaving CC but doesn't actually justify choosing Pi
  • ~Complaints are specific to VSCode integration; Claude Desktop or other harnesses like ThinkRail solve these issues