What Is Gridifcation(musicalform.substack.com)
461 points by gumby 6 days ago | 218 comments
tl;dr: "Gridification" is the post-production practice of quantizing recorded human performances to a machine-perfect timing grid, a technique the author's tempo analysis shows is near-universal in today's pop hits but absent in 1975's. The Musical Form Institute argues this erases the "felt time" and historical presence of the performers, and has launched a "Certificate of Embodied Production" to certify recordings that preserve unquantized human timing.
HN Discussion:
  • ↑Personal anecdotes confirm gridification/quantization strips life and interest from recordings
  • ↑Modern music feels boring and perfect, masking rather than showcasing talent
  • •Quantization emerged from practical needs of distributed/non-simultaneous recording, not just aesthetic choice
  • ↓The article overstates its case with forced rhetoric, like the kick/bass alignment claim
  • ~Broader economic and technological shifts in music production add nuance the article misses