Passkeys are a trap(nonfunctional.substack.com)
1030 points by laurex 2 days ago | 541 comments
tl;dr: Passkeys, pushed by the FIDO Alliance, bundle many different credential types under one confusing name, and the standard includes "remote attestation" — a feature that lets websites verify you're using approved hardware, software, and OS. While attestation isn't widely enforced yet, the author warns it could eventually be used to lock users out of alternative operating systems, custom browsers, or self-written software, undermining user control. The recommended alternatives are TOTP (authenticator apps) for convenience or hardware security keys like YubiKey for high security without OS-level lock-in.
HN Discussion:
  • ↓Attestation concerns are overblown since it's not actually enforced in practice
  • ↑Passkeys lack portability and tie users to specific devices, validating concerns
  • ↓Article misses that passkeys work well in password managers and offer great UX
  • ~The alarmist tone and title undermine the article's legitimate points
  • ↑Remote attestation is a genuine freedom threat worth sounding alarms about