So you think you could be an electrician?(asteriskmag.com)
475 points by zdw 13 days ago | 436 comments
tl;dr: A veteran tradesman pushes back on the popular narrative that the trades are a lucrative, AI-proof alternative to college, noting that college degrees still yield higher lifetime earnings, actual tuition costs are lower than sticker prices suggest, and trades carry serious risks of injury and death. He also argues the best union trade jobs are highly competitive—not easily accessible—and that AI will likely reshape construction by bypassing manual dexterity and automating the increasingly complex cognitive demands of modern trades work.
HN Discussion:
  • ↑All manufacturing and trade jobs carry significant bodily injury risks, confirming the article's safety concerns
  • •Trades are heterogeneous with many specializations, adding nuance beyond the article's generalizations
  • ↑Firsthand experience confirms the article's claims about hazards and hierarchies in the trades
  • ↑Market saturation would undermine the AI-proof trades narrative by driving wages down
  • ↓For people without good white-collar prospects, trades remain a genuinely better option than the article allows