The last time my family was replaced by technology(manuel.darcemont.fr)
323 points by megalomanu 13 days ago | 625 comments
tl;dr: The author's great-great-grandfather, a farrier in rural France, pivoted to become a mechanic when cars arrived, preserving his underlying purpose—helping people get around—even as the technology changed. Drawing a parallel to developers anxious about AI, the author argues that what truly motivates most engineers is building things and solving problems, not writing code itself. The lesson: let go of the "how" to hold on to the "why."
HN Discussion:
  • ↑Author clarifies the piece is a personal tribute, not a dismissive lesson about adapting
  • ↓The analogy ignores real human destruction and immediate suffering of displaced workers who can't easily retrain
  • ↓The horse-to-car analogy fails because there's no next frontier for displaced knowledge workers to move into
  • ↑Agrees that code is just a tool and problem-solving is the real purpose, so embracing AI makes sense
  • ↓Philosophical reframing is a luxury for the employed; it doesn't help those already replaced