What even is an OS now?(sockpuppet.org)
295 points by fratellobigio 18 days ago | 442 comments
tl;dr: Thomas Ptacek is leaving Fly.io to build an AI-native phone with Kurt, arguing that AI will dissolve the boundary between programmers and users, leading to a world where most apps are personal, disposable creations built on-the-fly rather than prefab software from strangers. He contends this makes traditional operating systems—designed to sandbox software from untrusted third parties—obsolete, and that today's phones are still rooted in a 1970s paradigm of running fixed-function applications. The new device won't run traditional apps; it'll generate them on demand from user prompts.
HN Discussion:
  • ↓Article misunderstands what an OS actually is at a technical level
  • ↓People won't want to generate their own apps; LLMs aren't capable enough for this vision
  • ↓Security model still requires treating AI-generated code as untrusted, undermining the premise
  • ↓History of BASIC/HyperCard shows most users never wanted to build their own software
  • ~Apps are the obsolete concept, not OSes; future is a single AI assistant doing tasks directly