Why is the liver so weirdly regenerative?(dynomight.substack.com)
566 points by jbotz 19 days ago | 291 comments
tl;dr: The author argues that most of the body is "fragile crap" because evolution deliberately traded regenerative capacity for reduced cancer risk—shorter telomeres, non-dividing neurons, and limited healing all serve as cancer defenses. The liver is unusually regenerative because its detoxification role demands it, paying the cancer tax as a cost. But the theory is messy: the small intestine achieves both high regeneration and low cancer via a clever villi/stem-cell conveyor belt, though this is energy-expensive and structurally impossible for most organs.
HN Discussion:
  • •Expert recommends foundational cancer biology textbook for deeper understanding of the topic
  • ↓Lack of regeneration is due to insufficient evolutionary pressure, not a cancer tradeoff
  • ↓Article underestimates the importance and value of skin/wound healing capabilities
  • ↓Article's claim that neurons never regenerate is scientifically outdated
  • ~Human oddities like menopause are better explained by social structure than cancer tradeoffs