I said no and Apple said yes(dbushell.com)
858 points by thatslast 22 days ago | 692 comments
tl;dr: After upgrading to macOS 27, the author found Apple had removed the toggle to disable Apple Intelligence, re-enabling AI features despite a prior explicit opt-out and consuming 22.28 GB of disk space. Some features can only be hidden via Screen Time parental controls, and unkillable Siri processes persist even when Siri is off. The post frames this as part of a broader pattern in the AI industry of ignoring user consent.
HN Discussion:
  • ↑Linux is the only OS that respects user autonomy; abandon Mac/Windows
  • ↓Author misunderstands the Apple Intelligence Report setting; it's just a transparency log, not data transmission
  • ↑Apple's UI patterns never allow a genuine 'no' to nudges and AI features
  • ~Apple does provide documented ways to disable Apple Intelligence via user guides/parental controls/configuration profiles
  • ↑Regulation should mandate the right to refuse features during installation and updates