DHS is using obscure law to snoop on journalists, non-profits, unions(theguardian.com)
440 points by firefax 11 days ago | 106 comments
tl;dr: DHS is using 19 USC 1509—a customs summons statute meant for import/duty investigations—to demand records from Google, T-Mobile, Meta, and others without judicial oversight, targeting journalists (including Georgia Fort and Don Lemon), unions (SEIU, CWA), and non-profits (Sunrise Movement) with no apparent customs nexus. Critics, including former DHS officials, call it a deliberate end-run around the Fourth Amendment, and DHS has repeatedly withdrawn summonses when challenged in court to avoid an adverse ruling that would curtail the tactic.
HN Discussion:
  • Companies share blame for complying with unenforceable summonses instead of challenging them
  • DHS budget is wasteful and could be better spent on healthcare
  • This surveillance behavior resembles authoritarian regimes and is inherently wrong
  • ~This is part of a larger authoritarian takeover that won't be stopped by legal challenges
  • Users should adopt decentralized tools and avoid SMS/centralized platforms for protection