Beware Management Consultants(about.iceland.co.uk)
604 points by KolmogorovComp 3 days ago | 155 comments
tl;dr: A satirical parable about two rowing teams: the Green team wins with 7 rowers and 1 captain, while the Red team loses with 7 captains and 1 rower. Rather than fix the obvious problem, Red team management hires consultants who recommend restructuring into more layers of leadership, then fire the rower after losing again, reward the managers, and ultimately outsource rowing to India — a critique of how consultants and executives protect hierarchy while blaming workers.
HN Discussion:
  • Shares related example of founder-driven company culture critiquing bureaucracy
  • Self-reflection about being complicit in the very bureaucracy the article critiques
  • Agrees consultants have misaligned incentives and management overvalues change
  • Extends the satire by mocking agile methodology as another layer of consultant-driven nonsense
  • ~Blames corporate leaders/hierarchy-brain rather than just consultants for the dysfunction