AI has access to a vastly larger working memory than the human brain(davidepiffer.com)
601 points by rzk 6 days ago | 490 comments
tl;dr: AI's apparent superiority at mathematics may stem less from better reasoning than from a vastly larger "working memory" — its context window acts as an enormous external symbolic scratchpad that lets it track assumptions, intermediate steps, and constraints far beyond human cognitive limits. This advantage is most pronounced in mathematics because the domain is built from explicit, unambiguous symbols and verifiable steps, but less useful in informal domains involving hidden causes or ambiguous concepts. The author likens current AI to a von Neumann–style amplifier of speed and breadth, rather than an Einstein capable of reframing problems entirely.
HN Discussion:
  • Intelligence is largely about superior memory and recall, supporting the article's thesis
  • AI's advantage comes from tireless brute-forcing and ability to leverage negative results, extending the article's argument
  • LLMs are knowledgeable but not truly smart, useful as supplements rather than replacements for human reasoning
  • The memory advantage has underappreciated implications like verbose code and long machine-generated proofs
  • The author's credibility is questionable due to their background