“Gravity is worth asking about”(unsung.aresluna.org)
207 points by nozzlegear 7 days ago | 136 comments
tl;dr: Riffing on John Gruber's posts about creeping ads on Apple surfaces, the author argues that in UI design there's no stable middle ground: once you allow one setting, exception, or ad, "infinity" inevitably follows (see Chrome's right-click menu or iOS screenshot options bloating over time). Because digital interfaces are infinitely extensible and each incremental addition seems harmless in isolation, complexity accretes unless someone is empowered to arbitrarily say no.
HN Discussion:
  • Apple has lost its legendary simplicity and is cluttering its OS with ads and confusing settings
  • ~Minimalism goes too far when it removes functionality needed by non-mainstream use cases
  • Business/org incentives reward adding features over pruning, explaining the gravity toward complexity
  • Bloat isn't a taste failure but a symptom of OS architecture that can't compose apps
  • ~Quality decline traces to individual senior champions leaving or disengaging, not systemic gravity