New York City to ban deceptive subscription practices(theguardian.com)
553 points by randycupertino 18 hours ago | 273 comments
tl;dr: Starting October 1, New York City will fine companies $525 per subscription (plus back fees) if they don't offer a simple cancellation method, targeting gyms, streaming services, and other recurring charges. A separate proposed rule would require sellers—including landlords, hotels, and rental car agencies—to advertise total upfront prices inclusive of mandatory "junk fees," which would notably affect NYC's rental market where hidden fees inflate advertised rents. The moves follow the failure of similar Biden-era federal rules struck down in court or watered down by industry lobbying.
HN Discussion:
  • ~Skepticism about enforcement effectiveness and potential loopholes like California's restaurant carveout
  • The 'landmark' framing is overblown since California already has similar rules
  • Sharing personal experiences with deceptive subscriptions and fees that validate the need for such rules
  • Praising this as legitimate government advocating for consumers against exploitation
  • ~Concerns about jurisdictional limits and expected industry lobbying for federal preemption