New York City to ban deceptive subscription practices(theguardian.com)
635 points by randycupertino 61 days ago | 337 comments
tl;dr: Starting October 1, New York City will fine companies $525 per subscription for making cancellations difficult, requiring simple opt-out mechanisms for recurring charges like gyms and streaming services. A separate proposed rule would force sellers—including landlords, hotels, and rental agencies—to advertise total prices upfront including mandatory "junk fees," which is particularly significant in NYC's rental market where hidden fees often add hundreds to monthly costs. The moves follow the failure of similar Biden-era federal rules and are part of the Mamdani administration's affordability push.
HN Discussion:
  • ~Skepticism about enforcement effectiveness given loopholes seen in similar California laws
  • ~The law isn't as landmark as claimed since California already has similar rules
  • Sharing personal experiences of deceptive subscription/fee practices that validate the need for such regulation
  • This represents legitimate government advocating for consumers against exploitative companies
  • Questioning whether city-level regulation can meaningfully enforce these rules against national companies