EU Parliament greenlights Chat Control 1.0(patrick-breyer.de)
1446 points by rapnie 1 day ago | 702 comments
tl;dr: The EU Parliament failed to block "Chat Control 1.0" after a rejection motion fell short of the required absolute majority (314-276 against, but needed 361), reinstating suspicionless scanning of private messages on US platforms like Gmail, Instagram, and Discord until 2028. End-to-end encrypted services like WhatsApp remain exempt, and critics argue the mass scanning is ineffective—99% of Meta's reports involve previously known material, and 48% of alerts aren't criminally relevant. Negotiations over a permanent "Chat Control 2.0" regulation resume in September.
HN Discussion:
  • EU procedural manipulation exposes it as undemocratic and heading toward totalitarianism
  • This legislation undermines EU credibility on privacy and digital rights
  • Users should adopt privacy tech like Tor, VPNs, and Signal to evade surveillance
  • This mirrors historical tyranny that justified constitutional protections like the US 4th Amendment
  • Member states use EU as blame-laundering mechanism for unpopular domestic laws