EU now one step away from reviving private message scanning rules(cyberinsider.com)
431 points by ggirelli 19 hours ago | 164 comments
tl;dr: The European Parliament voted 331-304 to fast-track legislation reviving the EU's expired "Chat Control 1.0" regulation, which allowed platforms like Gmail and Messenger to voluntarily scan private communications for CSAM. A binding vote is scheduled for July 9, where opponents need an absolute majority of 361 MEPs to block it. This is separate from the stalled "Chat Control 2.0" permanent regulation, and notably the Council's own Legal Service has warned that even voluntary generalized scanning may violate Article 7 of the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights.
HN Discussion:
  • Privacy erosion is incremental and industry groups keep pushing surveillance under child safety pretexts
  • Article conflates 1.0 (voluntary scanning of non-E2EE) with the more dangerous 2.0, causing unnecessary alarm
  • This legislation will keep returning until it passes, so vigilance and contacting representatives is essential
  • Technical workarounds like custom E2EE clients could bypass scanning, questioning the law's practical effectiveness
  • ~Skepticism about the urgency given repeated similar headlines that never seem to materialize