CarPlay Is Additive(caseyliss.com)
568 points by sprawl_ 50 days ago | 708 comments
tl;dr: Rivian's CSO defended the company's refusal to support CarPlay by claiming it "takes over every single pixel," but the author counters that standard CarPlay doesn't take over the whole screen (only optional CarPlay Ultra does), and that CarPlay is entirely optional for drivers anyway. The author argues CarPlay is purely additive—if Rivian's native UI is great, customers won't use it—and says he won't buy a Rivian until they add support, despite otherwise loving the vehicles.
HN Discussion:
  • CarPlay provides valuable cross-vehicle consistency and personalization that native systems can't match
  • CarPlay is a must-have feature and dealbreaker when purchasing a new vehicle
  • Rivian's native infotainment is good enough that CarPlay isn't missed in practice
  • CarPlay is actually inferior to well-designed native systems like Tesla's for key tasks
  • Modern infotainment systems broadly are becoming dangerous attention-grabs, regardless of CarPlay