An American Privacy Emergency(scottaaronson.blog)
347 points by flowercalled 13 hours ago | 103 comments
tl;dr: A June 2026 Commerce Department directive (DAO 216-26) bans differential privacy, noise infusion, and swapping from Census Bureau and BEA publications, restricting confidentiality protection to 1970s-era techniques like coarsening and suppression. Cynthia Dwork and other leading researchers argue this politically motivated order—tied to Project 2025 and aimed at enabling citizenship data extraction—will force a lose-lose tradeoff between useless statistics and violations of the Census Act's confidentiality requirements, since coarsening alone can be trivially reversed via basic algebra when multiple statistics interact. They call on scientists to pressure Congress to rescind the directive.
HN Discussion:
  • Quoting and highlighting the article's key claims about the directive's bans
  • Providing action links to contact legislators as the article urges
  • Asking what the political motivation behind targeting these techniques is
  • Article lacks technical detail and relies on contrived scenarios to favor its preferred solution
  • Author is being bombastic and the piece isn't really about privacy