Streaming services' obnoxiously loud ads become illegal on July 1 in California(arstechnica.com)
272 points by speckx 23 hours ago | 89 comments
tl;dr: Starting July 1, California law extends the federal CALM Act's ad-volume rules to streaming services, banning obnoxiously loud ads. The MPA and Streaming Innovation Alliance opposed the bill, citing technical challenges with server-side ad insertion across varied encoding pipelines and output devices like TVs, tablets, and phones. Compliance will likely require streamers to integrate file-based and real-time loudness controls into their ad workflows—similar to existing broadcast practices, which still drew 1,700 FCC complaints in 2024.
HN Discussion:
  • Streaming services' technical complaints are unconvincing excuses for not fixing their own systems
  • Similar loudness/brightness issues exist on other platforms and should also be addressed
  • This closes a needed loophole already addressed for broadcast TV
  • Personal experience confirms ad loudness is a real and annoying problem
  • Questions or reflections on the legislative approach and technical definitions involved