The 'papers, please' era of the internet will decimate your privacy(expression.fire.org)
810 points by bilsbie 14 hours ago | 368 comments
tl;dr: Australia's under-16 social media ban, now being emulated by the UK, EU, and various US states/federal proposals like KOSA, forces platforms to verify users' ages via government IDs, biometrics, or third-party services—creating massive privacy risks, as evidenced by a recent Discord breach exposing 70,000 Australians' ID data. Beyond data breach exposure, these mandates effectively end online anonymity, chill speech on sensitive topics, and may extend to cracking down on VPNs. The author argues this "papers, please" infrastructure of surveillance, once built, will be nearly impossible to dismantle—and isn't even effectively keeping kids off social media.
HN Discussion:
  • ~Technical solutions like anonymous credentials could enable privacy-preserving age verification
  • ~Privacy advocates need to articulate concrete harms more clearly to persuade ordinary voters
  • Age verification is a slippery slope toward mandatory digital ID for all aspects of life
  • Opting out of the digital world is the personal response to these privacy threats
  • These systems endanger everyone via breaches and coercion, not just those discussing sensitive topics