The 'papers, please' era of the internet will decimate your privacy(expression.fire.org)
1138 points by bilsbie 57 days ago | 605 comments
tl;dr: Australia's under-16 social media ban, which is largely failing to keep kids offline, has forced platforms to mandate biometric or government ID verification through third-party services—already resulting in a Discord breach exposing 70,000 users' IDs. The UK, EU, and others are pursuing similar "Australia-plus" laws, with UK officials even floating restrictions on VPNs. In the US, 19+ states and federal proposals like KOSA are heading the same direction, building a surveillance infrastructure that ties online speech to identity verification and creates serious risks for privacy, anonymity, and free expression.
HN Discussion:
  • ~Technical solutions like anonymous credentials could enable privacy-preserving age verification
  • ~Privacy advocates need more concrete examples of harm to convince ordinary voters
  • These ID systems endanger everyone via breaches, coercion, and ID theft, not just dissidents
  • This is a slippery slope leading to mandatory digital ID for all aspects of life
  • Personal response is to opt out, disconnect, or retreat to airgapped/physical alternatives