"Don't You Just Upload It to ChatGPT?"(correresmidestino.com)
458 points by speckx 2 days ago | 365 comments
tl;dr: A freelance translator recounts a gym encounter where a government HR director casually suggested she just "upload documents to ChatGPT" to finish her work faster. The translator argues that AI is a tool—useful for spell-checks, glossary building, and style-guide compliance—but it hallucinates, skips sentences, and lacks the human judgment needed for real translation, so professionals shouldn't be paid less for using it. The kicker: the same civil servant admitted she doesn't use AI at her own job because "it's not reliable enough."
HN Discussion:
  • AI is great for others' fields but inadequate for one's own expertise, supporting the article's irony
  • Translation quality matters deeply, and bad translations (human or AI) ruin works
  • AI capabilities are advancing rapidly and will eventually match human translators
  • ~AI translation is good enough for casual use but not professional quality
  • LLMs can't handle less-spoken languages or specialized domains, reinforcing need for human translators